Design a Friendlier Forum: Class Project Inspired by Digg’s Paywall-Free Beta

Hook: Turn exam-room theory into a platform people actually want — without paywalls

Students: tired of design briefs that stop at a wireframe or an essay? Imagine a class project where you build a complete, launch-ready alternative to paywalled social platforms — one that prioritizes community, fair moderation, and sustainable monetization without locking users behind a paywall. Inspired by Digg’s paywall-free public beta revival, this assignment teaches real product skills: policy design, UX mockups, monetization experiments, and launch playbooks you can include on a portfolio or pitch to campus incubators.

Why this project matters in 2026

By early 2026 the social-platform landscape shifted: several legacy sites experimented with paywalls or premium tiers, and some users pushed back. Digg’s decision to reopen a paywall-free public beta in January 2026 is emblematic — communities want access, not fences. At the same time, regulators and platform users demand stronger content moderation, transparency, and ethical monetization models. Your class project prepares you to design products that meet those expectations.

What students will build (deliverables)

• Moderation policy pack: community guidelines, enforcement matrix, appeal flow, and escalation protocols.
• Monetization alternatives: 3–5 ethically grounded, paywall-free revenue plans with revenue projections.
• UX mockups & prototypes: onboarding, community hubs, moderation tools, and mobile-first interfaces (Figma or equivalent).
• Launch & growth plan: 8–12 week beta timeline, seeding strategy, metrics dashboard, and PR plan.
• Risk & compliance checklist: data policy, safety audit, accessibility checklist, and rudimentary legal considerations.

Class structure: How to run this project (8–12 weeks)

Use a sprint-based structure with clear roles. This replicates real product cycles and builds teamwork skills.

Week-by-week roadmap (sample 10-week program)

1. Week 1 — Kickoff & research: Competitive analysis (Digg’s paywall-free beta, Reddit alternatives, federated platforms), user interviews, and persona creation.
2. Week 2 — Define product principles: Accessibility, transparency, anti-paywall stance, and community-first moderation philosophy.
3. Week 3 — Moderation policy skeleton: Draft rules, clear violation tiers, and enforcement timelines.
4. Week 4 — Monetization ideation: Brainstorm and shortlist paywall-free revenue strategies; sketch rough financials.
5. Week 5 — UX flow & wireframes: Onboarding, community discovery, posting, and moderation UX.
6. Week 6 — High-fidelity mockups: Figma prototypes for mobile & web; accessibility review. When handing off designs to developers, teams can follow structured handoff patterns similar to logo and brand handoffs (logo handoff package best practices).
7. Week 7 — Beta launch plan: Seeding tactics, initial moderator recruitment, and PR messaging.
8. Week 8 — Metrics & analytics: Define KPIs, build a dashboard (Tableau, Google Data Studio, or open-source alternatives).
9. Week 9 — Playtesting & user feedback: Run closed beta tests, collect usability and moderation feedback, iterate UI and policies.
10. Week 10 — Final presentation & handoff: Pitch deck, demo, and submission of artifacts suitable for a portfolio.

Roles & assessment rubric

Divide teams of 4–6 students into roles to replicate a startup product team. Rotate roles across sprints so everyone practices several skills.

• Product Lead: owns roadmap and stakeholder presentations.
• UX/UI Designer(s): builds mockups and prototypes.
• Community Manager / Moderation Lead: writes policy and designs enforcement flows.
• Business/Monetization Analyst: models revenue and fundraising scenarios.
• Data & Analytics: defines KPIs and dashboarding.

Grading rubric (example)

• Product vision & user research — 20%
• Moderation policy clarity & ethics — 20%
• UX quality & accessibility — 20%
• Monetization feasibility & creativity — 15%
• Launch plan & KPIs — 15%
• Presentation & team collaboration — 10%

Designing moderation that scales — practical templates

Moderation is the hardest, highest-impact part of any social platform. Aim for policies that are transparent, fast, and appealable. Below are practical elements students should include.

Community guidelines: concise + taggable

• Principle statement (1 sentence): e.g., “We prioritize respectful debate, evidence-based posts, and the safety of marginalized users.”
• Do / Don’t bullets for 6 common behaviors: harassment, doxxing, misinformation, spam, sexual content, illegal activity.
• Examples: short positive/negative post examples to remove ambiguity.

Enforcement matrix (actionable)

• Tier 1 — Minor: warning + auto-educational modal.
• Tier 2 — Repeat/Mid: temporary posting suspension (24–72 hrs).
• Tier 3 — Severe: long suspension + manual review.
• Tier 4 — Safety/Legal: immediate removal + law-enforcement flagging if required.

Appeals & transparency

• Auto-email + in-app appeals tracker visible to the user.
• Human review SLA: initial review within 72 hours, escalations within 24 hours.
• Quarterly transparency reports: take-down stats, appeal outcomes, and policy changes.

“A policy users understand is enforceable at scale.”

Monetization without paywalls — 8 practical alternatives

In 2026, many platforms and regulators prefer open access. Here are tested and experimental revenue paths for a paywall-free social platform.

1. Ethical, contextual advertising

Serve ads with strict relevance and privacy-first constraints: contextual ads, no cross-site tracking, and an opt-out data cooperative. This model aligns with regulatory pressure from privacy laws in 2024–2026 to limit fingerprinting. For operational playbooks around consent and measurement see Beyond Banners: Measuring Consent Impact.

2. Creator tipping & microdonations

Built-in tipping (low friction, low fee). Integrate multiple rails: credit card, mobile payment, and micropayments via Lightning or Web Monetization protocols, which matured significantly by 2025.

3. Voluntary subscriptions & perks

Optional supporter badges and minor UX perks (custom themes, expanded profile analytics). These perks should never restrict core content.

4. Grants & institutional sponsorships

Partner with universities, NGOs, or foundations to fund topical communities (e.g., climate, public health). This diversifies revenue without charging end-users.

5. Marketplace & affiliate commerce

Marketplace for community-led courses, study guides, or merchandise. Revenue share models where creators profit and platform takes a commission. See platform choices for selling courses and marketplace strategies: Top platforms for selling online courses in 2026.

6. Enterprise moderation-as-a-service

Offer moderation toolkits or API access to smaller communities and forums for a subscription fee. This monetizes the platform’s moderation expertise.

7. Data co-op analytics (privacy-preserving)

Provide aggregated, anonymized insights to researchers or institutions under strict governance — users opt in and revenue is shared via a cooperative model.

8. Events & community sponsorships

Host virtual and in-person events, workshops, or competitions with sponsor partnerships and ticket sales.

UX mockups & interaction patterns: what to prototype

Avoid generic Reddit clones. Focus on community discovery, low-friction moderation, and transparency features that reassure new users.

Core screens to design

• Onboarding: progressive disclosure of rules; optional interest tagging; lightweight privacy choices (short vs. detailed).
• Community hub: curated highlights, pinned resources, moderator notices, and visible moderation activity logs.
• Post composer: inline fact-check suggestions, tag recommendations, and content warnings.
• Moderation console: triage queue, evidence panel, templates for standardized responses, and appeal links. Consider tools reviewed in the lightweight matchmaking & lobby tools field review for small-team moderation workflows.
• Profile & reputation: transparent reputation score, trust badges for moderators and verified experts.
• Monetization flows: tipping widget, supporter signup modal, and transparent fee disclosures.

Interaction patterns that reduce friction

• Inline micro-education: when users cross a rule, show a quick explainer rather than an opaque ban.
• Cooldown nudges: reduce flame wars with timed posting delays on heated threads.
• Community moderation tools: allow community-initiated review flags with reputation-weighted inputs.

Launch plan: seeding a healthy, paywall-free community

Launching a community-first platform is about quality of the first 10,000 interactions, not vanity metrics. Use these tactical steps in your class plan.

Pre-launch (4–6 weeks)

• Recruit initial communities: faculty groups, student clubs, hobbyist collectives.
• Train volunteer moderators: role-play sessions, moderation handbook, and script repository.
• Create onboarding assets: explainer videos, community playbooks, and a code of conduct.

Beta launch (weeks 0–6)

• Invite-only rollouts with seeded content to model desired behavior.
• Staged feature releases: launcher must disable monetization toggles until community standards are stable.
• Daily moderation briefings and weekly feedback loops with active users.

Post-beta scale (months 2–6)

• Open invite with clear welcome flows and educational nudges.
• Quarterly transparency reports and policy updates based on data.
• Measure retention cohorts and prioritize features that improve first-week retention.

Metrics that matter (KPIs for a classroom dashboard)

Pick a few leading indicators. Avoid chasing vanity numbers.

• DAU/MAU ratio: aim for 20–30% for healthy engagement in early stages.
• First-week retention: percent of users who return within 7 days.
• Time-to-resolution for moderation: average hours to complete an action.
• Appeal success rate: percent of appeals overturned (can indicate fairness or policy clarity issues).
• Revenue per active user: tests across monetization experiments.
• Trust & Safety score: composite of user surveys, content takedown rates, and report-to-action ratios.

Tools & templates students should use

Ship fast with modern collaboration tools — many free or discounted for students in 2026.

• Figma: high-fidelity mockups and interactive prototypes.
• Miro or FigJam: product mapping and user journeys.
• Notion: documentation hub for policies, playbooks, and handoffs.
• Google Data Studio / Metabase: simple KPI dashboards for class grading and iteration.
• Open-source moderation tools: review systems like OpenAI’s safety toolkits (or open-source equivalents) for triage workflows.

Legal, ethical, and accessibility checklist

Even a class prototype must consider these constraints. Include a one-page legal & ethics memo in the deliverables.

• Privacy policy in plain language and a short “What we collect” bullet list.
• Accessibility audit: WCAG 2.1 AA baseline, keyboard navigation, alt text for images.
• Child safety: age gating and parental controls where applicable.
• Intellectual property: clear content licensing options for creators. Use a transmedia IP readiness checklist when planning cross-platform content.
• Regulatory flags: awareness of Digital Services Act (EU) or evolving US platform rules as of 2025–2026. Also review EU data residency and regulatory signals: EU Data Residency Rules (2026).

Case study lab: Lessons from Digg and 2025–26 trends

Digg’s public beta in January 2026 — which removed paywalls — highlights a broader lesson: users and communities push back against access barriers when the product’s community value is high. Class teams should study Digg’s messaging, which emphasized openness and community curation, and compare it with platforms that doubled down on paywalls. For observations about platform migration and how platform drama affects installs, see When Platform Drama Drives Installs: a Publisher’s Playbook.

Other trends from late 2025 and early 2026 to analyze:

• Privacy-first ad models replacing third-party tracking.
• Proliferation of federated and interoperable social spaces emphasizing data portability.
• Improvements in AI-assisted moderation tools that can triage and summarize context but require human oversight for appeals. Teams should consider decision-plane and auditability approaches from Edge Auditability & Decision Planes.
• Regulatory scrutiny pushing platforms toward transparency reports and clearer appeals processes.

Common pitfalls and how to avoid them

• Pitfall: Overloading moderators with vague rules. Fix: use an enforcement matrix and templates.
• Pitfall: Monetization that restricts access. Fix: separate perks from essential access and prioritize voluntary contributions.
• Pitfall: Ignoring accessibility. Fix: include WCAG checks in UX sprints and test with screen readers.
• Pitfall: Chasing growth over quality. Fix: prioritize retention, trust metrics, and seeded high-quality content.

Student deliverable checklist (printable)

1. One-page product vision & persona sheet
2. Moderation policy & enforcement matrix (editable doc)
3. 3 monetization scenarios with 12-month projections
4. Figma prototype (mobile + web flows)
5. 10-week launch plan + seeded community list
6. Analytics dashboard link and KPI definitions
7. Accessibility & legal one-pager

How instructors can grade or present this to panels

Invite industry judges (product managers, community leads, alumni) for demo day. Use live prototypes and role-played moderation scenarios for higher-fidelity assessment. Encourage judges to score teams against real-world constraints: moderation scalability, cost of moderation per 1,000 users, and initial revenue runway.

Advanced strategies & future-proofing (2026 and beyond)

Prepare teams to think beyond the MVP:

• Interoperability: design APIs for federation (ActivityPub or compatible) to allow healthy migration and discoverability across networks. See engineering guidance on edge-first developer patterns at Edge-First Developer Experience (2026).
• Privacy-preserving personalization: client-side models or differential privacy to recommend content without data capture.
• AI-human hybrid moderation: use AI for initial triage and human moderators for contextual adjudication and appeals.
• Community ownership: experiment with token-lite co-ops where revenue decisions are governed by elected community councils (non-speculative models).

Actionable takeaways — what your team should do this week

1. Form teams and assign roles using the recommended role map.
2. Complete a competitive teardown focusing on Digg’s 2026 beta messaging and two other platforms.
3. Draft a one-page moderation principles document and test it in a 30-minute role-play.
4. Create the first Figma wireframe for onboarding with a visible community code-of-conduct step.

Final thoughts

Designing a friendlier forum — inspired by Digg’s paywall-free comeback and the 2026 emphasis on community-first design — is a practical, portfolio-ready class project that teaches product thinking, ethics, and real-world launch skills. Students who complete this project will have artifacts employers and incubators value: policy documents, prototypes, revenue models, and a tested launch plan.

Call to action

Ready to run this in your course? Download the starter kit (moderation templates, grading rubric, Figma base files, and a 10-week syllabus) and run your first sprint this semester. If you want a tailored syllabus or a guest critic from industry for your demo day, reach out — help your students ship something the internet actually needs.

Related Reading

• Future Predictions: Monetization, Moderation and the Messaging Product Stack (2026–2028)
• Beyond Banners: An Operational Playbook for Measuring Consent Impact in 2026
• Edge-First Developer Experience in 2026: Shipping Interactive Apps with Composer Patterns
• Portfolio Projects to Learn AI Video Creation: From Microdramas to Mobile Episodics
• Quick Win Templates: Announcement Emails Optimized for Omnichannel Retailers
• The Traveller’s Tech Layer: Smartwatch, Smart Lamp, and Accessories That Actually Make Trips Easier
• Cashtags 101: How Finance Creators Can Build Authority on Bluesky
• DIY Herbal Mocktail Syrups for Dry January (and Beyond)
• Monetize Your Swim Coaching with Serialized Content: A Playbook for Subscription Growth
• Community-Led Growth: Recruiting Moderators and Advocates on New Social Hubs